How Much Is a Cocktail in NYC? 2026 Prices From 17 Bar Menus, From $10 in Brooklyn to $29 in Manhattan

Drink prices · New York City · Updated November 19, 2026

  • 17 bar menus, Manhattan and Brooklyn
  • Prices read November 18, 2026
  • 8.875% city sales tax worked out
  • Happy hour drinks at $8 at ours
  • Heated backyard garden at 118 Christopher Street
Marina Charny, owner of The Beer Garage

Marina Charny, Owner, The Beer Garage
Published November 19, 2026 · Facts verified November 18, 2026

How much is a cocktail in NYC? The honest answer is a range, and the range is wide: a classic margarita is $10 at one Park Slope bar and a specialty cocktail is $29 at a West Village restaurant across the East River. Averages quoted without a source do not help much when the bill arrives.

So we wrote the prices down. We read the cocktail menus that 16 bars in Manhattan and Brooklyn publish on their own websites, from neighborhood rooms to some of the best-known cocktail bars in the city, and set our own menu from 118 Christopher Street beside them. Every price below is copied as printed, before tax and tip, with the date we read it.

Short answer

A cocktail in NYC costs $10 to $29 on the 17 bar menus we read on November 18, 2026, before tax and tip. The cheapest drink on each list ranges from $10 to $21, and the middle of those 17 starting prices is $17. Manhattan lists start near $19 and Brooklyn lists near $12, and a Manhattan cocktail bar usually charges $19 to $24.

At The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street, spritzes are $13, classics $14 to $15 and our seven signature cocktails $15, the lowest starting price of the ten Manhattan menus we read. Our happy hour list puts a margarita or a whiskey sour at $8. New York City adds 8.875% sales tax, so a $15 cocktail comes to $16.33 before the tip.

A bar is in this table if its own website prints a price beside its cocktails. The price column gives the cheapest and the dearest regular cocktail on each list, and the next column says what most of the list costs. Large-format drinks, flights and vintage pours are left out of the range and named in the notes below the table.

Cocktail prices printed on the own websites of 16 New York City bars and The Beer Garage West Village, read November 18, 2026, cheapest starting price first. US dollars, before 8.875% sales tax and tip.
Bar and address Cocktails, as printed Most of the list Borough
Rullo’s, 560 5th Ave $10 to $14 Eight Back to Basics classics at $10; five Elixirs at $14 Brooklyn
Gowanus Gardens, 256 4th Ave $10 to $18 House cocktails $11 to $15; Bloody Mary $10 all day Brooklyn
The Owl Farm, 297 9th St $11 to $13 Highballs $11; cocktails and hot cocktails $13 Brooklyn
Skylark, 477 5th Ave $12 to $15 Seasonal cocktails $15; margarita $12 Brooklyn
The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher St $13 to $18 Seven spritzes $13; classics $14 to $15; seven signatures $15 Manhattan
LoFi, 341 2nd St $13 to $15 Most of 13 cocktails at $14 Brooklyn
Dante West Village, 551 Hudson St $15 to $26 Most $18 to $22; Negroni on tap $19 Manhattan
390 Social, 390 5th Ave $15 to $17 Cash or debit price; 3% more by card Brooklyn
Saint Eves, 471 12th St $17 Every seasonal cocktail and classic at $17 Brooklyn
The Clam, 420 Hudson St $17 to $20 Five cocktails on its dinner menu dated October 26, 2026 Manhattan
L’Artusi, 228 W 10th St $18 to $29 Seven specialty cocktails, most $21 to $24 Manhattan
Joseph Leonard, 170 Waverly Pl $19 All six cocktails Manhattan
Jeffrey’s Grocery, 172 Waverly Pl $19 One price for the whole cocktail list Manhattan
American Bar, 33 Greenwich Ave $19 to $20 Long drinks $19; signatures and spritzes $20 Manhattan
Katana Kitten, 531 Hudson St $19.50 to $23 Highballs $19.50; signatures $20 to $23 Manhattan
Superbueno, 13 1st Ave $20.50 to $22.50 Prices end in 50 cents Manhattan
Employees Only, 510 Hudson St $21 to $24 Classics $21; fancy cocktails and espresso martini $24 Manhattan

Left out of the ranges: Dante’s Negroni flight ($47), vintage 1970s Negroni ($90), caviar martini ($38) and Pornstar martini ($30); Superbueno’s seasonal tepache for two or four ($48.50 and $96.50); and our Long Island Iced Tea is the $18 in our range. Beer and wine drinks such as micheladas and mimosas are left out on every list. Zero-proof cocktails have their own page, mocktails in the West Village, where ours are $10.

Manhattan against Brooklyn

The borough explains more of the price than the drink does. On the ten Manhattan menus the cheapest cocktail runs from $13 to $21, and the middle of those ten starting prices is $19. On the seven Brooklyn menus it runs from $10 to $17, with a middle of $12.

The same classic shows the gap. A margarita is $10 at Rullo’s in Park Slope, $12 at Skylark and $13 at The Owl Farm and Gowanus Gardens. In the West Village it is $14 at our bar, and the margarita variations at Dante and Superbueno sit between $20.50 and $22.50.

Our bar is the exception in Manhattan. At 118 Christopher Street the cocktail list starts at $13 and stays at $15 for every signature, closer to a Brooklyn neighborhood price than to the $21 that Employees Only charges 348 feet from our door.

What a cocktail really costs after tax

Menu prices in New York City do not include sales tax. The combined state and city rate for New York City is 8.875%, per New York State’s own rate table, Publication 718, so every price on this page goes up before you add a tip.

Printed cocktail prices with New York City’s 8.875% sales tax added, rounded to the cent. Before tip.
Printed price Where you will see it With tax Four drinks with tax
$8 Happy hour margarita or whiskey sour at The Beer Garage $8.71 $34.84
$10 Classics at Rullo’s; Dante’s Martini Hour; The Clam’s happy-hour cocktail $10.89 $43.55
$14 Classics at The Beer Garage; Elixirs at Rullo’s; most of LoFi’s list $15.24 $60.97
$15 Signature cocktails at The Beer Garage; seasonal cocktails at Skylark $16.33 $65.33
$19 Joseph Leonard; Jeffrey’s Grocery; long drinks at American Bar $20.69 $82.75
$21 Classics at Employees Only $22.86 $91.46
$24 Fancy cocktails and the espresso martini at Employees Only $26.13 $104.52

One menu adds a line of its own. 390 Social in Park Slope prints two prices for each drink: the cash or debit price and a card price 3% higher, so a $16 cocktail there is $16.48 by card before tax.

Happy hour: the cheapest cocktails in NYC

The lowest cocktail prices in the city are happy-hour prices, and they come with days and hours attached. Here is what the menus we read print, as written:

  • The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street. Thirteen happy-hour drinks at $8, from a margarita, a whiskey sour, a gin and tonic and a vodka soda to sangria, prosecco and a michelada, plus a $5 well shot and a $12 beer and a shot. Ask at the bar or call 646-490-4301 for today’s happy hour hours.
  • Amity Hall Downtown, 80 West 3rd Street. Its location page advertises “$6 Cocktails for Happy Hour”.
  • Dante West Village, 551 Hudson Street. Martini Hour, $10, daily from 3:00 to 5:00 PM; the menu marks four martinis as not included.
  • The Clam, 420 Hudson Street. A $10 happy-hour cocktail, the Cucumber Cooler, Tuesday to Friday from 3:00 to 5:00 PM, with $5 beer and $10 wine.
  • Gowanus Gardens, 256 4th Avenue. $2 off the house and non-alcoholic cocktail menu, Monday to Friday from 3:00 to 7:00 PM, and $10 margaritas on Tequila Tuesdays.
  • Katana Kitten, 531 Hudson Street. Happy-hour cocktails at $14 and $15, Monday to Friday from 4:00 to 6:00 PM.
  • Saint Eves, 471 12th Street. $14 cocktails, Monday to Thursday from 5:00 to 7:00 PM.

In Brooklyn, our Park Slope bar at 148 5th Avenue runs its happy hour Monday to Thursday from 3:00 to 7:00 PM with $7 draft beers and $1.50 oysters and clams, per our OpenTable listing, from a kitchen that is 100% gluten-free. Our West Village happy hour guide and Park Slope happy hour guide list every nearby bar’s hours.

How much is a martini, a margarita, a Negroni or a spritz in NYC?

Searches often name the drink rather than the cocktail list. These are the lowest and highest prices printed for each one on the 17 menus, and what it costs at our bar.

Prices for four common cocktails on the menus read November 18, 2026, before tax and tip. Variations on each drink are counted under it.
Drink Lowest printed Highest printed At The Beer Garage
Martini $13, Mezcal Martini at The Owl Farm $24, espresso martini at Employees Only ($38 for Dante’s caviar martini) $15
Margarita $10, Rullo’s $22.50, Mushroom Margarita at Superbueno $14, or $8 at happy hour
Negroni $13, The Owl Farm $23, Mezcalito at Dante ($90 for its vintage Negroni) $14
Spritz $13, The Beer Garage and The Owl Farm $20, American Bar $13, seven of them

Spritzes have a page of their own: our spritz bar in the West Village guide compares every spritz printed on our street, and ours, from Aperol to Hugo, are $13.

Our prices at 118 Christopher Street

The Beer Garage West Village prints its full drinks menu on its online ordering page, so you can read every price before you walk in. Our seven signature cocktails are $15 each: Pineapple Sunset, Orange Manhattan, Sparkling Lychee, Mezcalrita, The Hanky Panky, Afternoon Siesta and Passiontini.

The classics are $14 for a margarita, mojito, Negroni, mule, whiskey sour, Old Fashioned or Bloody Mary, and $15 for a martini, sidecar or amaretto sour. Seven spritzes are $13, the zero-proof list is $10, and 37 beers and ciders sit on the same menu, most of them at $10.

How much is a cocktail in NYC at The Beer Garage: the bar at 118 Christopher Street, where signature cocktails are 15 dollars and spritzes 13
The bar at 118 Christopher Street, where the cocktail list starts at $13. Photo: The Beer Garage.

Behind the bar is a heated backyard garden, so a $15 cocktail comes with a seat outside in November. We are three minutes from the Christopher St-Stonewall 1 train, open from noon Sunday to Friday and from 11:00 AM on Saturday. For a game with your drink, the front room has the TVs; for a quieter one, take it to the garden.

Our Park Slope bar at 148 5th Avenue in Brooklyn is the other half of The Beer Garage: a full bar, $7 drafts and $1.50 oysters at happy hour, and a menu headed “100% gluten-free”, so a guest with celiac disease orders from the same list as the rest of the table.

Why the same drink costs more in one room

The menus themselves show where the money goes. Employees Only clarifies several of its fancy cocktails with milk and force-carbonates others, and charges $24 for them. Dante pours a Negroni on tap for $19 and a vintage 1970s Negroni for $90. L’Artusi’s dearest cocktail, at $29, is built on a ten-year-old rye. A neighborhood bar like Rullo’s prints its classics under one heading, Back to Basics, at $10.

Price also follows the rent and the room. The ten Manhattan menus here are all in the West Village and the East Village, and most of them belong to restaurants with a bar, where the cocktail list is priced alongside dinner. Our bar sits on the same streets with a sports bar’s prices: a list built for a second round, not for one drink at a reservation.

Before you order: four things menus do not tell you

Prices change with the season; Dante, L’Artusi and The Clam date their menus, and all three have printed a new one since early October. Tax of 8.875% and a tip come on top of every price here. One Park Slope bar charges 3% more by card. And every bar on this page serves alcohol only to guests 21 and over, so bring a valid ID.

Find your price

Two questions, one cocktail plan, from the menus we read on November 18, 2026.

1. Where are you drinking?



How we checked

On November 18, 2026 we opened the drinks page of each bar on this list and every menu PDF linked from it, by script and in a browser for the pages that only show their menu as an image or load it with JavaScript, and copied each cocktail price as printed. A bar made the list if its own website prints a price for its cocktails. We then read our own West Village ordering menu the same day.

The starting price is the cheapest regular cocktail on each list. The middle figures are medians of those starting prices: 17 menus in all, ten in Manhattan and seven in Brooklyn. The tax rate is New York City’s combined rate from New York State’s Publication 718.

What this page does not do

It does not rank the drinks, and nobody visited the other bars to taste them. It is a reading of 17 printed menus, not a survey of every bar in the city, and the middle price describes these menus only. Nobody paid to be listed, and The Beer Garage is ours, as the byline says.

A $15 cocktail and a heated garden on Christopher Street

The Beer Garage West Village, 118 Christopher Street, is open Monday to Thursday noon to midnight, Friday noon to 1:00 AM, Saturday 11:00 AM to 2:00 AM and Sunday noon to 10:00 PM. The Beer Garage Park Slope, 148 5th Avenue, entrance on Douglass Street, is open Monday to Thursday 3:00 to 10:00 PM, Friday 2:00 to 11:00 PM, Saturday 1:00 to 11:00 PM and Sunday 1:00 to 10:00 PM, with a kitchen that is 100% gluten-free.

Call for a table, a group booking or today’s happy hour hours.

Frequently asked questions

How much is a cocktail in NYC?

On the 17 bar menus we read on November 18, 2026, from $10 to $29 before tax and tip. Manhattan cocktail bars mostly charge $19 to $24; Brooklyn neighborhood bars $10 to $17. At The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street, cocktails start at $13 and signatures are $15.

What is the average price of a cocktail in NYC?

Across the 17 menus we read, the middle starting price is $17: $19 for the ten in Manhattan and $12 for the seven in Brooklyn. That describes these menus, not every bar in New York City. With 8.875% sales tax, a $17 cocktail comes to $18.51 before the tip.

How much is a martini in NYC?

From $13 for a mezcal martini at The Owl Farm in Park Slope to $24 for the espresso martini at Employees Only, and $38 for Dante’s caviar martini. A martini is $15 at The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street, and Dante West Village pours $10 martinis from 3:00 to 5:00 PM daily.

Where can I get a cheap cocktail in NYC?

At happy hour. The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street, prints thirteen happy-hour drinks at $8, including a margarita and a whiskey sour. Amity Hall Downtown advertises $6 happy-hour cocktails, Dante West Village pours $10 martinis from 3:00 to 5:00 PM daily and The Clam prints a $10 cocktail on weekday afternoons. In Brooklyn, Rullo’s lists eight classics at $10 all day.

Does the menu price include tax in NYC?

No. New York City adds 8.875% sales tax, the combined state and city rate in New York State’s Publication 718. A $15 cocktail is $16.33 with tax and a $21 cocktail $22.86, before the tip.

How much is a spritz in NYC?

From $13 to $20 on the menus we read. The Beer Garage, 118 Christopher Street, prints seven spritzes at $13, The Owl Farm in Park Slope pours a spritz on tap at $13, Dante West Village charges $18 and $19 and American Bar $20.

The verdict

How much is a cocktail in NYC? Plan on $19 to $24 at a Manhattan cocktail bar and $10 to $17 at a Brooklyn neighborhood bar, then add 8.875% tax and a tip. For the West Village at close to a Brooklyn price, The Beer Garage at 118 Christopher Street pours $13 spritzes, $14 classics and $15 signatures, with $8 cocktails at happy hour and a heated garden out back.

Sources and references

Related reading: Cocktail bar in the West Village · Cocktail bar in Manhattan · Cocktail bar in Park Slope · Spritz bar in the West Village · Mocktails in the West Village · Happy hour in the West Village · Best bars in the West Village

Marina Charny, owner of The Beer Garage

Marina Charny
Owner, The Beer Garage (West Village and Park Slope)


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *