Best Bar Snacks and Wings in Park Slope, 2026

Food · Park Slope · Updated October 13, 2026

• Ten menus read September 25, 2026
• Wings from $1.60 to $2.33 apiece
• Walks measured from 148 5th Avenue
• Prices before tax and tip
• Park Slope kitchen: every plate gluten-free

Ask for the best bar snacks and wings in Park Slope and you usually get a list of names. We wanted numbers. On September 25, 2026 we read the menus of ten kitchens within a 40 minute walk of our bar, ours included, and divided each wing price by the number of wings the menu promises.

Four of the ten do not print both a price and a count, and we are one of them, so those cells are left empty rather than guessed. Our own room, The Beer Garage in Park Slope, wins on one thing: the whole kitchen is gluten-free. On price and on sauces, the tables below point elsewhere.

Best bar snacks and wings in Park Slope, priced per wing

Each row comes from the kitchen’s own menu, read on September 25, 2026. The per-wing figure is plain division, the printed price over the printed count, before tax and tip. Walking times are from our door at 148 5th Avenue, measured in Google Maps walking mode on the same day.

Three things stand out. The cheapest printed wing at a bar is at Freddy’s, $1.67 each, though it is the second longest walk on the list. On every menu with more than one size, the larger orders work out cheaper per wing than the smallest; the biggest drop is at Bonnie’s, from $2.00 to $1.60 at twenty.

Only Drums & Flats sells more than twenty at once. And McMahon’s and Park Slope Ale House print identical prices, $14 for six and $24 for twelve.

Two notes on fairness. Bonnie’s Grill is a restaurant that serves beer, not a bar, and the prices above are the ones on its own website, which says they are lower than on other online ordering sites. McMahon’s also posts a separate Barclays Center event menu that lists its wings at $12 and $22, so on an arena night, ask which menu is running.

Which wing for which night

No kitchen wins every category, so here is where four of them are strongest, using only what each one publishes. The wider case for each room on game nights is in our comparison of Park Slope sports bars.

Nachos, cheese curds and sharing plates

Wings are half the order. These are the snacks that turn up on several menus, grouped so you can compare like with like. A blank description means the menu lists the dish without one.

Two details worth knowing. The Dram Shop’s own site says kids eat free on Saturdays, which helps if the snack run includes children. And The LayUp publishes a full snack list without a single food price, so call (347) 677-3112 if the number matters to you.

Our Park Slope snack menu, plate by plate

Here is the small-plates side of our Park Slope menu exactly as printed. Everything comes out of one gluten-free kitchen, which is why there is no separate gluten-free menu to ask for. For how that kitchen works, see our guide to the sports bar with fully gluten-free food in Brooklyn.

Past the snacks, the menu runs to three personal pizzas at $20 to $28 and the BG’s Famous Burger at $24. At the very bottom, a line invites anyone who wants a full dinner to ask for our “Wild menu”. That one is not posted online, so ask at the bar.

One gap we should own: the menu prints $14 for Garage Wings but not how many come on the plate. Until it does, our per-wing cell stays blank, the same treatment we gave our neighbors.

Gluten-free nachos and bar snacks in Brooklyn: what the menus label

Ask for gluten-free nachos and bar snacks in Brooklyn and most answers are guesses. We can only speak for the menus we read on September 25, 2026, all within a 40 minute walk of 5th Avenue in Park Slope, so this is a Park Slope answer with a Brooklyn question, and we say so.

On those menus, exactly one kitchen labels every plate gluten-free, and it is ours: the Park Slope menu is headed “100% gluten-free”, so the $21 chicken nachos with avocado, beans, jalapeno and mozzarella, the $13 guacamole and chips, the $13 fried pickles and the $36 sampler need no separate question. The nachos at The Dram Shop, The Commissioner, McMahon’s and Park Slope Ale House carry no gluten-free label, which does not mean they contain gluten, only that the kitchen has not said.

Two other labels exist. The Double Windsor marks its “Everything But The Wings” sweet potato plate gluten-free at $11, and Bonnie’s Grill labels a bread swap and a blondie. For the wider case, including our Brooklyn room’s dinner menu, see the guide to a sports bar with fully gluten-free food in Brooklyn and the notes on gluten-free food near Barclays Center.

When each kitchen is open

The hours below are each venue’s own, read on September 25, 2026. Door hours are not kitchen hours: only Park Slope Ale House and The Double Windsor publish when their kitchens stop, so for late food anywhere else, call first.

For wings before an afternoon game, Bonnie’s opens at 9:00 AM and McMahon’s and The Dram Shop at 11:00 AM; we open at 3:00 PM Monday to Thursday and 1:00 PM on weekends. After midnight, Freddy’s, Uncle Barry’s and McMahon’s are open every night, and The Commissioner, Drums & Flats and The Dram Shop on some nights, but none of them publishes a kitchen closing time.

Before you go: three warnings

200 Fifth is closed. The old sports bar at 200 5th Avenue still turns up on some listing and booking sites. It closed in 2020: Patch reported on June 30, 2020 that it would not reopen after the pandemic shutdown.

The LayUp prints no food prices. Its online menu names every snack, including a 4-piece and an 8-piece wing order, but prices only its cocktails and mocktails. Call before you compare.

Black Horse Pub is not on this page. Its website at 568 5th Avenue refused every request we made, so we could not read a menu, and we do not quote prices from review sites.

Pick your plate

Two questions, sixteen answers, all taken from the tables above.

How we priced this

Frequently asked questions

Where are the best bar snacks and wings in Park Slope?

It depends on what you need. For the lowest price per wing at a bar, Freddy’s Bar at 627 5th Avenue charges $10 for six. For the most sauces and orders of up to 100, Drums & Flats at 56 5th Avenue. For a kitchen that is entirely gluten-free, The Beer Garage at 148 5th Avenue, where wings are $14. Every price was read from the kitchen’s own menu on September 25, 2026.

Which Park Slope bar has the cheapest wings?

Freddy’s Bar at 627 5th Avenue, at six wings for $10, about $1.67 each. Bonnie’s Grill at 278 5th Avenue, a restaurant rather than a bar, lists 20 wings for $32, or $1.60 each, on its own website. Drums & Flats gets down to $1.75 a wing on an order of 100.

Where can I order 50 or 100 wings in Park Slope?

Drums & Flats at 56 5th Avenue lists 50 wings for $90 and 100 for $175, in six sauce styles. Bonnie’s Grill tops out at 20 for $32, and McMahon’s Public House and Park Slope Ale House each sell a dozen for $24.

Are there gluten-free wings in Park Slope?

Yes. The Beer Garage at 148 5th Avenue runs a kitchen that is 100 per cent gluten-free, so its $14 wings in BBQ, buffalo or mango habanero are gluten-free, and so are the nachos and the sampler. That is true of the Park Slope location only. None of the other nine menus we read marks its wings gluten-free.

Which Park Slope bar has a wings happy hour?

Park Slope Ale House at 356 6th Avenue prints one: wings for $12 from 4:00 to 6:00 PM Tuesday to Thursday and from noon to 6:00 PM on Friday, with tater tots and fried pickle chips at $5. The Dram Shop at 339 9th Street also puts four wings on its $7.75 happy hour snack menu, weekdays from 11:00 AM to 6:00 PM and Saturday until 3:00 PM, and Saint Eves at 475 12th Street sells wings at $2 each from 5:00 to 7:00 PM, Monday to Thursday, both read September 29, 2026.

Where can I get wings late at night in Park Slope?

Freddy’s Bar at 627 5th Avenue is open until 4:00 AM and McMahon’s Public House until 2:00 AM, every day, and Drums & Flats stays open until 2:00 AM on Fridays and Saturdays. None of them publishes a kitchen closing time, so call ahead. The Beer Garage closes at 10:00 PM Sunday to Thursday and 11:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

Where can I get gluten-free nachos and bar snacks in Brooklyn?

On the ten Park Slope menus we read on September 25, 2026, the only kitchen that labels every plate gluten-free is The Beer Garage at 148 5th Avenue, where chicken nachos are $21, guacamole and chips $13, fried pickles $13 and the sampler platter $36. The Double Windsor labels one sweet potato snack gluten-free and Bonnie’s Grill a bread swap and a blondie; no other nachos we read carry a label. We did not read menus outside Park Slope for this page.

The verdict

The best bar snacks and wings in Park Slope are not in one place. Price points to Freddy’s and, if you are buying twenty, Bonnie’s Grill. Sauces and big orders point to Drums & Flats. Happy hour points to Park Slope Ale House, or to The Dram Shop, where it starts at 11:00 AM. And if anyone at the table eats gluten-free, it points to us at 148 5th Avenue, where nothing on the menu needs a second question.

Sources and references

• The Beer Garage, Park Slope menu and beergarageny.com hours, read September 25, 2026.
• Drums & Flats menu and sports page; Uncle Barry’s, read September 25, 2026.
• The LayUp Bar menu, McMahon’s Public House menus (main and Barclays event) and The Commissioner food menu, read September 25, 2026.
• Bonnie’s Grill menu and Park Slope Ale House dinner and happy hour menus, read September 25, 2026.
• The Dram Shop menu, Freddy’s Bar food menu and The Double Windsor online menu, read September 25, 2026.
• “200 Fifth Bar In Park Slope Closes After Three Decades”, Patch, June 30, 2020.
• Google Maps walking mode, from 148 5th Avenue to each venue, measured September 25, 2026.

Related reading: Sports bar in Park Slope · Best sports bar in Park Slope · Sports bar with fully gluten-free food in Brooklyn · Gluten-free food near Barclays Center · Sports bar near Prospect Park · Where to watch NBA in Park Slope · Good bar for a group birthday in Park Slope · Happy hour in Park Slope · Craft beer bar in Park Slope · Craft beer bar in Brooklyn · Oyster happy hour in Park Slope · Gluten-free restaurant in Park Slope · 100% gluten free restaurant NYC